Warren Grimes
It’s been a turbulent Spring. The team has lost seven players who
transferred, four of them who were starters for most of the year (and a fifth
who was in the regular rotation). Public
accounts suggest that at least some of the players felt mal treated. Discontent at whatever level may have been
exacerbated by the NCAA chaos generated by NIL and open transfer rules. Congress is considering legislation to
address some of these issues, but Stanford must focus on what it can control.
I have no inside information on the source of the
discontent. Coaches are people and, like
everyone else I know, make mistakes. As a life-long teacher, I made my share of
them. I was fortunate to learn and benefit from
them. As Mark Twain said: "Good
decisions come from experience. Experience comes from making bad
decisions."
So can the current head coach and her staff learn from past
mistakes? Coaching for a high profile
team means operating in a fishbowl. Teachers
are judged by their students. So too
with a coach, but coaching is less tolerant and less forgiving of
mistakes. Yes, players will be acute observers
of a coach’s performance, but those who pass judgment on a coach include players’ families, athletic
administrators, alumni, fans, future recruits, the press, and probably Emily
Post (if she follows basketball). Tolerance
for a coach’s mistakes will be much lower than for most teachers.
The one plus that a coach has is that if she wins, tolerance
for mistakes suddenly becomes much greater.
Mistakes will be ignored and the AD will instead offer a contract renewal
with a salary hike. I’m sure that Tara
VanDerveer made her share of mistakes – and probably learned from many of
them. Meanwhile, she was winning games at
a very high rate, along with league and tournament championships.
In the one extended conversation I had with VanDerveer, she
told me that she could never have coached at Stanford the way that Pat Summitt coached at Tennessee. At the time of the
exchange, Summitt had just locked her players out of a new locker room, intending
this as an incentive for more intense practices. That wouldn’t work at Stanford, VanDerveer
said -- the players wouldn’t put up with it.
What Coach VanDerveer said a decade or more ago must be truer today, when
players are free to transfer with no penalty.
So for Coach Paye, the key is building morale, chemistry,
and a winning team. She will have the
benefit of a new Assistant Coach, said to be skilled at player development, and
seven new players, three transfers and four freshmen. The five returning veterans include one
starter (Swain) and two regular rotation players (Eschmeyer and Ijiwoye). All three of the transfers either started or
were major rotation players for their former teams. Jordyn Wheeler, a freshman guard, is
performing very well for Team Canada this summer.
I hope that Coach Paye and her staff will favor carrots over
sticks and can build the team chemistry and morale needed to be a tournament
team next season. No guarantees, but I’m
with Mark Twain.